You might be better off selling them via a local fish club. You are in the lucky position to have plenty in your area. I used to live in Kent, OH, and it's one of the things I miss. There are wonderful fish clubs in Akron, Medina, Youngstown, and others. All of them have websites and will auction fish for you at their meetings. Or you can sell them for a better price at big auctions they run once or twice a year. Plus for cichlids there is the Ohio Cichlid Association in Cleveland. They have a buy/sell forum for members on their website.