Cichlid Fish Forum banner

Keyholes Fighting Question

1894 Views 1 Reply 2 Participants Last post by  illy-d

We are re-establishing a 55 gal tank and would like it to be a community tank (the tank was previously dedicated to a single large green severum). My husband picked out 3 youngish keyhole chiclids. We have had keyholes previously and never had any problems with them fighting. The new fish did OK for the first few days, then two of them started chasing and attacking the 3rd. I moved him to a smaller 10 gallon tank. Shortly after doing so, the remaining pair spawned.

The question is whether or not there is any way to have the 3 keyholes live in the same 55 gallon tank? It appears that I have two males and a female. We plan to buy other non-chiclid fish to add to the tank. Will this help to make them less territorial?

Oh yes, my tank does have rock work, a terracotta pot, as well as a few live plants. I tried rearranging the rock work to make more hiding places. When I added the 3rd fish back, they still chased him around.

Any tips? Am I doomed to having two tanks set up or getting rid of one of the males? I would really like to get all three of them to co-exist in the same tank if possible.

1 - 2 of 2 Posts
I had the same problem... The keyhole pair I had would not tolerate any other keyholes in their 55 gallon tank.

They were okay with other fish that did not resemble them in anyway - such as Bolivian Rams.

I did find that once the spawning started the pair also took to hunting my rummynose tetras - I had succes keeping 'deeper bodied' tetras like Serpaes with the keyholes but the 'noodle' shaped ones like rummies and neons always became lunch.

I think if I had of raised the keyholes from little guys with the rummies it could have worked - but I waited until they were mature and added them as dither fish - it didn't work...
1 - 2 of 2 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.