They both buffer to 8.3 in my tanks, the eco complete has aragonite in it for buffering so they should be the same as far as buffering. The eco complete is available in different colors, I got the sahara sand , which is the darker stuff, and yes, it does bring out some more color in the fish. I think the eco complete is also supposed to contain trace elements to better replicate the water conditions of the lakes. The eco complete is kind of expensive, but I think it's worth it, and if I was setting up another tank today, I would buy it again.