Putting a sump on that size of a tank is almost always cheaper than running two canisters, but sumps do tend to be more difficult to set up and sometimes, maintain. If you don't want to drill your tank or do a lot of set up work, a sump wouldn't be for you. The 100-200 dollars more you spend with canisters may be worth it if you want ease of maintenance and setup. I personally like sumps as I have some experience with them, so set up and maintenance are not an issue for me. They also do a slightly to significantly better job in terms of filtration (depending on the style of sump). I also like the feeling of knowing you just saved a lot of money. Call me cheap, but I sure do like the extra cash lol.
I've always had HOB and canisters but until recently my largest was a 75--all FW. That being said, I recently set up a 120 (drilled) so I've done A LOT of reading/research on sumps. Since both HOB & canisters are essentially plug-n-play, neither has an advantage over the other from that stand point. That being said, canisters have the potential to hold more media (both mechanical & biological) and this is important for cichlids since they can be "dirty" fish.
If your budget allows, I'd suggest two FX6s.
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.