Haplochromis sp. ''Dayglow'' Cichlid-Forum  
  Home  |  Library  |  Forum  |  Species Profiles  |  Aquarium Gallery  |  Product Reviews  |  Retailer Reviews  |  Classifieds  |  Sponsors  |  Clubs Chat empty  
Retailer Reviews
7721 reviews on 2185 retailers!

RetailersMail-Order FishUSNY Atlantis Tropical Fish Hatchery
Atlantis Tropical Fish Hatchery
City, State: Gardiner, NY
ZIP: 12525
Phone: (845) 255-5871
Web site: Click here
User Ratings: 
Quality of Stock:
Available Variety:
Compiled from 85 reviews
  Login to Review » User Reviews    
Found: 85 reviews Page  1 2 3 4 5 - View all
bkw has used this retailer 3-10 times. January 31, 2007
Overall Rating: 
"Amazingly Beautiful Fish Delivered to My Door"
I have ordered a total of 48 fish from Atlantis. All fish have arrived alive and healthy to my midwest home in the middle of the winter (it was negative 2 degrees during the last shipment). The fish are incredibly beautiful. The selection of fish is very impressive. Peter was also very helpful with post delivery questions about foods, and he checked to ensure the delivery arrived safely. Many of the fish were larger than advertised, which was also a pleasant surprise. You will be VERY happy with Atlantis.
giants has used this retailer 3-10 times. January 7, 2007
Overall Rating: 
I am absolutely blown away by this facility! Their selection is unbelievable! I've visited Atlantis a few times and am amazed by their selection. Their tanks are well maintained and you can see first hand the quality of their breeding stock. I could not be more pleased with my purchases and will definitely be back! I have purchased fish from other stores and hobbyists in the past and have not been completely satisfied. I plan on looking no further! You have to try Atlantis. You wont be disappointed!
toffee67 has used this retailer 1 time. January 4, 2007
Overall Rating: 
"Great prompt service, nice quality fish!"
This was a great experience from start to finish. Peter answered all of my questions in a quick and thoughtful manner. The fish are great and the selection is huge! I would recommend Atlantis to anyone, Thanks!
Tembwe has used this retailer 1 time. January 1, 2007
Overall Rating: 
"Great Fish, Great Customer Service!"
All fish arrived alive and well, not to mention looking spectacular! I highly recommend doing business with Peter and Atlantis.
leongeo has used this retailer 1 time. January 1, 2007
Overall Rating: 
"Great Experience From Begining to End"
Peter and his team are very friendly and professional. A+++++ experience. Will do business with them again for sure.
jtuey has used this retailer 2-3 times. December 20, 2006
Overall Rating: 
"Excellent Stock and Service"
I have visited Atlantis Tropical Fish several times as I live only 1/2 hour away. My experience with the business has been wonderful. They have a fantastic selection, the fish are in excellent health, and most importantly the staff and owner are knowledgable,courteous, and inviting. If you live within an hour or two of this facility, you have to take a trip there (they are open to the public only on Saturdays) at least once. You won't be disappointed. I have purchased a # of Tropheus (sp. Black Kiriza) from Atlantis and could not be more satisifed.
junger08 has used this retailer 3-10 times. March 12, 2009
Overall Rating: 
"Great Fish and excellent service"
I have bought fish from Atlantis four times. Their fish are excellent and always exceed my expectations when they arrive. I chose atlantis because of its diverse selection of wild mbuna and there worry free service. The fish are always packaged very well for their flight from New Jersey to Appleton wisconsin. A great experience and I will continue to do business with Peter in the future. If you want great fish with great service and Shipping look no further.
Obi has used this retailer 2-3 times. December 4, 2006
Overall Rating: 
"Fantastic selection, and great service"
I have been to Atlantis twice now, in Gardiner, NY. They are friendly, helpful, and have excellent quality cichlids that they obviously take great care of.

With almost 1,000 tanks to choose from, the selection is almost overwhelming, and the packing was superb as I didn't lose even one fish on the 3.5 hour drive home.

I highly recommend Atlantis. You won't be disappointed.
nandusnandus has used this retailer 1 time. December 3, 2006
Overall Rating: 
"Excellent Service"
I purchased a group of Crenicichla sp. "cobra" from Peter @ half the price that I've seen them @ other retailers. He was accomodating, in that he held the fish for a month while I was out-of-town. He was always prompt when returning e-mail and calls. He also followed-up, to make sure that the fish had arrived alive and well.
The fish were also packed well. I would certainly purchase from ATFH again.
teknikAL has used this retailer 3-10 times. September 28, 2006
Overall Rating: 
I have been aware of Atlantis Tropical Fish from the website and impressed with their stock list and prices. I also heard of Peter Rubin, he being the first importer of line bred red Peacocks from Germany, or so the story goes. It wasn't until I emailed to inquire about making a purchase that the two came together.

I had literally lived down the road from Atlantis for many years and had turned around in the Atlantis driveway on it's dead end country lane in Gardiner, NY a few times. At the time I thought it was a seafood distribution business.

I noticed a thread in a forum about Atlantis, and I was pointed to Aquabid as he had posted some fish there for the first time. I ended up buying five A. comp. black Nangu fry through Aquabid.
I arranged a visit to pick up my fish and check out his hatchery. Peter's operation uses air power to run UG and sponge filtration, eliminating any cross contamination of the water as in a centralized filter system. He had a great variety of fish with many wild caught for sale. With the support of a 2.2 million gallon fish farm in Lakeland, Florida, the stock is diverse with beautiful pond raised specimans.

I went to pick up my Nangu comps, but left with much more. I was able to properly match some Tang species I have, to try to pair them up; i.g. Julidochromis regani Kigoma.

Peter opens his hatchery doors in Gardener, NY (80 or so miles North of NYC, near New Paltz) for sales by appointment on Saturdays and Monday
  Login to Review » Page  1 2 3 4 5 - View all    
Ratings are submitted by Cichlid-Forum users based upon their own subjective views and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Cichlid-Forum.com. CF disclaims any responsibility for the accuracy of information contained in reviews submitted by users, or for any damage or liability arising from the content of any review appearing on Cichlid-Forum.com. All product information on this site, including descriptions and specifications, is based soley on information made available by manufacturers. CF disclaims any responsibility for this information or the products listed. Product information may be inaccurate and is subject to change without notice. You should confirm all information before relying on it by contacting either the manufacturer or vendor with any questions about the products or the information presented.

Copyright © 2020 Cichlid-Forum.com. All Rights Reserved.
Login to access your personal folder.

0 User(s) in Chat
92600 Members
869710 Posts
665 Classifieds