Haplochromis sp. ''Dayglow'' Cichlid-Forum  
  Home  |  Library  |  Forum  |  Species Profiles  |  Aquarium Gallery  |  Product Reviews  |  Retailer Reviews  |  Classifieds  |  Sponsors  |  Clubs Chat empty  
Retailer Reviews
7723 reviews on 2185 retailers!

RetailersMail-Order FishUSNY Atlantis Tropical Fish Hatchery
Atlantis Tropical Fish Hatchery
City, State: Gardiner, NY
ZIP: 12525
Phone: (845) 255-5871
Web site: Click here
User Ratings: 
Quality of Stock:
Available Variety:
Compiled from 85 reviews
  Login to Review » User Reviews    
Found: 85 reviews Page  2 3 4 5 6 - View all
ericseyferth has used this retailer 1 time. June 29, 2017
Overall Rating: 
"They appear to be out of business"
Although the website is active and lists inventory there was no response to email and calling their telephone number resulted in a "this number is no longer in service" message.
michael21esposito has used this retailer 2-3 times. May 21, 2015
Overall Rating: 
"Great Knowledge / Selection"
Sean is the new owner and he has done a great job stocking and keeping a great variety of fish. He has a wealth of knowledge and is very helpful. I found his pricing to be reasonable. I have bought 6 fish from him and am buying 6 more this weekend. Atlantis is the only place to buy Cichlids!
dovetail has used this retailer 2-3 times. March 28, 2013
Overall Rating: 
"Best There Is"
Thank you ATLANTIS and Jon. My special guest arrived from Africa and is doing very well. Will invite more guests when I find more room.You guys ROCK.
BOB from Woodhaven
cichlid-gal has used this retailer 1 time. July 31, 2012
Overall Rating: 
"Great Vendor to Work with"
Just made my first wild purchase through Atlantis. Weather was very hot and I had some concerns about shipping all the way across county. Jon at Atlantis worked with me and we came up with a shipping plan. Fish arrived right on time and in great health. Loving my new wilds and will look to Atlantis again because the fish and the service are spectacular!!!
det_lions87 has used this retailer 1 time. June 12, 2012
Overall Rating: 
"Excellent communication and fish"
Very prompt in responding to all of my email inquiries. Held fish until my tank was fully setup and ready for the fish. Ordered 7 Multi's and recieved 8 that were in excellent shape and extremely healthy. A few days later and all fish are still doing great. Would recommend and will be buying from again in the future.
joeyrm has used this retailer 2-3 times. February 11, 2012
Overall Rating: 
"great resource"
I am lucky enough to be within 1:15 of their NY site. I have been stocking an all male Peacock tank and have found their prices and their fish to be the best. In fact I was at a higher end retailer paying 2.5 times Atlantis's price when their truck rolled in to drop of a dozen boxes of fish (won't make that mistake again). When they say 4"-5" fish, they actually underestimate. Can't beat the price or the quality
brice.phillips has used this retailer 1 time. February 1, 2011
Overall Rating: 
"Great from the start!"
Aside from FedEx doing their best to botch this delivery, Atlantis delivered outstanding specimens that were the promised size, sex and quality. I got a personal call from Jon to set up delivery and he made me comfortable with my first fish shipment ever. Picked up 5 large male Haps from him, and they were all at least the size he promised, some even a bit larger (thanks Jon)! Would certainly recommend to anyone, especially first timers. Came packed very well also (aside from FedEx destroying the box). Had enough heat packs to keep the fish bag water at 70+ degrees, even in 20 degree January Maryland weather. I thought "disaster ahead" when I saw the crushed box, but was then pleasantly surprised when I opened the box and saw a super happy Placidochromis Electra looking at me! 5/5 stars. I will certainly shop again with Atlantis.
slyman17 has used this retailer 1 time. December 22, 2010
Overall Rating: 
"Very happy"
WOW was the first word to come to my mind when I opened the shipping box. The fish were beautiful, especially the NGARA Flame Tail. Jon was great. Great communication throughout. Huge selection and good prices. I will definitely do business with them again.
mcfish has used this retailer 1 time. November 24, 2010
Overall Rating: 
"Tricoti &Cyp order"
I ordered 20 Benthochromis tricoti and 10 Speckleback Cyps. All arrived alive and in great shape. Will order from them again.
frosty1 has used this retailer 1 time. June 28, 2010
Overall Rating: 
"Impressive - purchased at NY Site"
Visited Atlantis NY location and purchased 2 Male Peacocks. Selection was impressive and all fish appeared to be in excellent condition. The facility was clean and organized with several hundred it seemed tanks in operation. Very very knowlegeable staff and made sure I received the best specimen available of each fish. I assure you these fish are kept in tanks not overcrowded and properly. I will make another trip again in a few weeks, now after seeing what they're all about, I'll call to reserve via phone knowing the stock is top notch.
Lawsman has used this retailer 1 time. April 12, 2010
Overall Rating: 
"First time buyer-will definitely buy againl "
I ordered from Atlantis some WC Julidochromis Marlieri last week. The fish arrived well packaged and looked great! This is my first time I have purchased from Atlantis, but it won't be my last. They responded promptly to my emails and was more than happy to discuss options over the phone. Very courteous and professional. Best of all, fish are awesome and settling in new home well!
Thank you Atlantis!
Nemo8840 has used this retailer 1 time. February 4, 2010
Overall Rating: 
chase0830 has used this retailer 1 time. December 18, 2009
Overall Rating: 
"Phenominal Service, Phenominal Fish!"
Simply put, Atlantis has it all. First off, Peter took his time answering every question I had about anything and everything. I even changed my order 3 times(called him 5 times) and he was a perfect gentleman every step of the way. He never sounded aggravated one bit. His knowledge of the fish he deals with is exceptional as well. I could go on-and-on but I think you get the picture. Now for the fish I received, AMAZING! I am doing an all male Peacock tank and wanted to make sure what I was getting were male. Well, the fish are all about 3-3.5" and have beautiful color already(Ruby Red, Maylandi Sulferhead, Lemon Jake, Red Shoulder). His packing job was excellent. They had to travel in 20 degree weather with heat packs but arrived in perfect condition. If using Atlantis I garantee you will not be disappointed. Can't wait to place my next order. Thanks Peter!
prov356 has used this retailer 1 time. November 23, 2009
Overall Rating: 
"Quality stock, quallity service"
I purchased some wild caught triglochromis otostigma along with some parcyprichromis nigripinnis. Very impressed with quality of stock and service and would highly recommmend Atlantis.
areuben has used this retailer 1 time. September 25, 2009
Overall Rating: 
"Beautiful stock - great service"
I have ordered many, many times on-line in the last 7-8 years, which is where I get most of my fish. This is the first time I have tried Atlantis and I was really impressed with the quality of the fish I received and the prompt service - from questions being answered to getting the fish shipped - flawless. I was a little reluctant ( as we always are with a new supplier) but with my regular suppliers unable to find me fish for close to a year, I thought I'd give Atlantis a try - they had the fish I was looking for. I ordered some synodontis granulosus, as well as some petricolas and the fish are REALLY NICE specimens - I am over the top with what I received.
Thanks Peter and hope to do business with you again.
  Login to Review » Page  2 3 4 5 6 - View all    
Ratings are submitted by Cichlid-Forum users based upon their own subjective views and do not necessarily reflect the opinions of Cichlid-Forum.com. CF disclaims any responsibility for the accuracy of information contained in reviews submitted by users, or for any damage or liability arising from the content of any review appearing on Cichlid-Forum.com. All product information on this site, including descriptions and specifications, is based soley on information made available by manufacturers. CF disclaims any responsibility for this information or the products listed. Product information may be inaccurate and is subject to change without notice. You should confirm all information before relying on it by contacting either the manufacturer or vendor with any questions about the products or the information presented.

Copyright © 2021 Cichlid-Forum.com. All Rights Reserved.
Login to access your personal folder.

0 User(s) in Chat
94151 Members
877568 Posts
685 Classifieds