Cichlid Fish Forum banner

50g big enough?

851 views 11 replies 5 participants last post by  Charles 
#1 ·
I have a tank that I'd like to set up but I'm not sure it'll work so I have a couple of questions.

50 gallon (36"x18"x19")
4-6 Multies plus whatever babies are hanging around (already have these guys)
1 Calvus
10(?) non-jumbo Cyps

Is this combination viable with this tank size? I know what I need to make aquascaping work for the multies and calvus but I've read that cyps need some sort of overhang to create top territory. Best way to accomplish this? How well will one calvus generally control a group of multies fry? I would possibly like to see some of the fry make it but would like the calvus to help with population control.
 
#5 ·
I am more worried by Cyps in a 36" tank than calvus being too big for multies. One small guy should be fine unless it grows big enough to threaten to eat the smallest female multies. Personaly in this size tank I would go for Paracyps rather the Cyps. Better at coping with short deap tanks.
All the best James
 
#8 ·
Seems no one else wants to go with this. All I can say is I kept 8 young adult Paracyps with a multie colony in a 36"x12"x15" for six months. Both bred fine. I did eventualy move the Paracyps to a bigger tank but was braking up that tank anyway. Temp "summer" tank in my garage.

Unless someone has tried it and got bad results I think its worth a pop in your tank.
My experience of Paracyps with calvus elsewhere in larger tanks is they get on fine as the Paracyps gently get out of the way of calvus and the calvus do not bother chasing them. The calvus prefering low down caves and shells and the Paracyps high up overhangs. But I have not kept em together in a small tank. :oops: :)

All the best James
 
#11 ·
Charles said:
you can keep paracyps. or non jumbo cyps in a 50g. I have done that many times before.
Yep 50g fine but a 36" long tank for Cyps long term? And with multies keeping em away from the bottom is kind of different from a species tank.
Interested in your experience mate not had success with adult Cyps myself in 36" long tanks in a communtity.

All the best James
 
This is an older thread, you may not receive a response, and could be reviving an old thread. Please consider creating a new thread.
Top